Rosaries Banned In Schools

How unfortunate. Apparently gangs have adopted this Catholic prayer tool as “part of their look”, so educators and public safety officials consider rosaries to be one more marker to track suspicious activity. And many schools have banned students from wearing them.

Recently this case in Oregon received nationwide attention:

Never did Jaime Salazar imagine that wearing a rosarylike crucifix to school would provoke a national stir.

But when the 14-year-old and his 16-year-old friend Marco Castro were suspended recently for refusing to remove the religious beads because they were “gang-related,” it thrust Oregon into the headlines and has triggered questions over the evolving role of rosaries in religion, fashion and street gangs.

Rosaries are not necklaces, and are not meant to be worn as such. But what one of the boys was wearing was apparently a crucifix, which is meant to be worn around the neck.

In Albany, Salazar said he knows exactly what a rosary is, and that’s not what he was wearing. It was a baby blue, beaded crucifix, he said, that makes him think of his mother.

Salazar said his problems began Feb. 15 after breakfast when Principal Chris Equinoa asked him to put away the crucifix, which he was wearing as a necklace.

“He told me it was a rosary, and it was gang-related,” said Salazar, who now carries the crucifix in his pocket. “I told him ‘No, it’s not a rosary. It’s a necklace and it’s Catholic.’ ”

When Equinoa asked him to go to the office, Salazar said he went home. Later, he received a letter notifying him he was suspended for five days for defiance and gang-related behavior.

Marco Castro did not return calls for comment, but he told the local Albany paper that Equinoa approached him Feb. 14 about his rosary, a white string of beads with a cross and an image of the Virgin Mary. He put it away but wore it the next day, then refused to remove it. He was suspended for three days.

More to the story?

Officials at South Albany High School, where Salazar and Castro returned to school last week, said policy prevents them from offering details about the suspensions.

“There’s more to the story, but because the boys are minors, we can’t talk about it,” said Jim Haggart, assistant to the superintendent for the Greater Albany Public School District.

I really don’t want to dwell on this one particular case, wherever the truth lies.

I just think schools are too heavy handed when it comes to these sorts of anti-gang fashion edicts.

Several years ago, bandanas became popular for girls to wear on their heads for the first time since I was a girl. I thought it was a cute trend, as there were many colors and designs to choose from, and it was a always a good choice for those bad hair days. Well, before long, the school put an abrupt end to the bandana trend by banning them because they were “gang related”. My oldest daughter was in the third grade at the time. Her little sister was in kindergarten. I don’t know how little K-6th grade school girls in a fairly conservative suburb could ever be confused with being gang members, but that was (and still is) the policy. And it’s silly.

Surrounded by rosaries at The Rosary Shop in McMinnville, shop owner Seth Murray is troubled by the idea of such a sacred symbol associated with gangs.He said public officials should focus on behavior, not rosaries.

“If someone is engaged in violence, it doesn’t matter whether they’re wearing a rosary,” he said. “You should not seek people out for that reason.”

I’m with that guy. And this guy, too, (even if he is from the ACLU):

David Fidanque, executive director of the American Civil Liberties Union of Oregon says educators should proceed with caution. Their intentions may be valid, but they run the risk of violating students’ rights, he said.

“When it comes to restricting any form of expression, school officials have a pretty high bar to cross,” he said. “They better have very specific evidence that’s more than just a hunch.”

Again, rosaries are not even meant to be worn around the neck, and most people who do it are doing so to make a fashion statement. But I’m not sure that it’s the school’s place to take a position on its usage. And it would help if school administrators could tell the difference between a crucifix and a rosary. They are most certainly impeding on a student’s religious rights by banning the wearing of a crucifix.

14 thoughts on “Rosaries Banned In Schools

  1. As a Catholic, I try to say the rosary once a week. It wasn’t always so with me, but it is very special. It bothers me when people don’t show it the respect it deserves.

    Like

  2. My friends, there is absolutely nothing wrong with wearing a rosary or other religious symbol, placing it on your wall, or in your car as a personal devotion, reminder or other genuine comfort. People — laity and religious — have been doing things like this for as long as there have been religious objects and people to wear them. If you don’t want to do it, then don’t, but please don’t tell other people it is wrong just because you don’t feel comfortable with it.

    That being said, there is obviously a personal, spiritual issue to be resolved if someone is wearing a rosary purely as a fashion accessory or the like (let alone a “gang sign”), or with a substantial misunderstanding about its meaning.

    Regarding the matter at hand: Unless the rosaries were being used in an act of violence, the principle in Albany clearly violated the students’ Constitutionally-protected civil rights regarding both freedom of expression and religion.

    Like

  3. HA!

    Seth, thanks for visiting my site.

    I’m glad you cleared that up because most people are taught these days, that the wearing of the rosary is improper and disrespectful, (probably because so many people have been wearing them in an improper and disrespectful manner).

    Like

  4. i wear my rosary everyday.. dat is not gang related.. who ever said its gang related then ur the stuipd ones.. free of reglious.. if u tell me to take it off i will said hell no and u cant make me take it off

    Like

  5. if u tell me to take it off i will said hell no and u cant make me take it off

    ur not the boss of me now. ur not the boss of me now. ur not the boss of me now and ur not sooo big.

    Like

  6. ima catholic in nyc queens as i think dat rosaries should be allowed. its called freedom of religion an if they wanna stop gang violence they should look out for weaponds and behavior problems in schools not what we is wearin

    Like

  7. I’m a Catholic and a teacher at a public school. I personally find it offensive to see non-Catholics and people who really don’t understand the purpose of Rosary beads to wear them around their necks. I wish that the schools where I work would do something about the Rosary wearing.

    Like

  8. The rosary should not be worn as a symbol of gangs. I know it has become a tradition for the Catholics to wear a crusifix around their necks but lets face it… does any one know what it means? If your mother beaten and murdered by a hammer trying to protect you, would you wear it around your neck?? Catholics need to open their eyes and see that repeating a prayer is not what God wants us to do as well as wear bright neon colored crosses around our necks.

    Like

  9. Catholics need to open their eyes and see that repeating a prayer is not what God wants us to do

    …and I’m sure you have a better suggestion? Do you even understand why Catholics repeat those prayers? I’m thinking that that’s pretty unlikely, and that you’re just a blithering idiot, but I’ll let you convince me otherwise.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s